The Crisis of Neoliberalism
This book examines "the great contraction" of 2007 - 2010 within the context
of the neoliberal globalization that began in the early 1980s. This new phase of
capitalism greatly enriched the top 5 percent of Americans, including capitalists and
financial managers, but at a significant cost to the country as a whole. Declining
domestic investment in manufacturing, unsustainable household debt, rising dependence on
imports and financing, and the growth of a fragile and unwieldy global financial structure
threaten the strength of the dollar. Unless these trends are reversed, the authors
predict, the U.S. economy will face sharp decline.
Summarizing a large amount of troubling data, the authors show that manufacturing has
declined from 40 percent of GDP to under 10 percent in thirty years. Since consumption
drives the American economy and since manufactured goods comprise the largest share of
consumer purchases, clearly we will not be able to sustain the accumulating trade
deficits. Rather than blame individuals, such as Greenspan or Bernanke, the authors focus
on larger forces. Repairing the breach in our economy will require limits on free trade
and the free international movement of capital; policies aimed at improving education,
research, and infrastructure; reindustrialization; and the taxation of higher incomes.
French economists Gerard Dumenil and Dominique Levy proceed from the somewhat heterodox
proposition that ruling ideas arise not from their persuasive power or inner logic but
from the interest of ruling groups... Dumenil and Levy move directly to the social and
political history that led us to this turn, the underlying situation in which such
intellectually bankrupt ideas could prevail. And what might become of a world that can no
longer sustain such beliefs... Though elements of their analysis proceed (in their words)
'a la Marx,' the book is scarcely what one might thereby expect-that is, the opposite of
[an] unreflective apologia for capitalism's premises... The two argue...that neoliberalism
is not a collection of theories meant to improve the economy. Instead, it should be
understood as a class strategy designed to redistribute wealth upward toward an
increasingly narrow fraction of folks.
This transfer is undertaken, they argue, with near indifference to what happens below
some platinum plateau-even as the failures and contradictions of the economic system
inevitably drive the entire structure toward disaster. Dumenil and Levy offer two
provocative and interlocking schemas. They decline the bluntest of Marxist oppositions,
which supposes a world divided only between owners and workers. But they equally abjure
the endless proliferation of categories and distinctions, the slippery slope of
micro-differences that leads to the paradoxical homily of conventional American thought:
that individuals are just that, and thereby classless-and that everybody is middle-class.
One might well see in this the shadow of Thatcher's other hyperbolic dictum of
neoliberalism: 'There is no such thing as society. There are only individuals and
families.' -- Joshua Clover The Nation 20110425 Amid the torrent of books on the 2008
financial meltdown and the North Atlantic 'great recession,' this important new
contribution from Paris stands out as an analytical beacon... Dumenil and Levy conclude
with a comparison of the aftermaths of 1929 and 2008, an assessment of the significance of
the crisis for U.S. hegemony and some sober prognoses on the social and economic order
likely to emerge in its wake.
The authors aspire to the kind of influence that Baran and Sweezy achieved with
Monopoly Capital some forty years ago-and on this reading, they deserve it. Like Monopoly
Capital, the analytical framework of Crisis of Neoliberalism uses some Marxian categories
and language, but leavened with (often implicit) elements of Veblen, Chandler, Galbraith,
Keynes and Polanyi. The result is a highly distinctive-and compellingly radical-approach,
which demands serious attention... By any measure, The Crisis of Neoliberalism
is a landmark intervention in the post-crisis debates... Young workers or students who
have had the misfortune to enter the labor force during the Great Recession will require a
far-reaching education in the history of capitalist crises if they are to begin to craft
an alternative exit from the present one. This book should help. -- Thomas Michl New Left
Review 20110701
400 pages, Paperback